You voted, we listened…here are the best local hardware stores in West Virginia

By Stephen Baldwin, RealWV

Back in the springtime, we were all working on those projects we thought about all winter. Whether we were servicing lawn equipment, starting a DIY project in the kitchen, or fixing that leaky faucet, we all go to the same place–our favorite local hardware store. 

Why do we go there? Because the folks behind the desk are always welcoming, friendly, and knowledgeable. If we tell them what we’re working on, they’ll ask us to follow them to a certain aisle and find exactly what we need. 

Local hardware stores are often unsung heroes of small towns across the state. They combine the personal and professional skills needed to solve problems large and small. 

Jack Tuckwiller is the owner of Martin & Jones in Ronceverte, WV. This is where he can be found most days, at least for a few minutes at a time, behind the counter helping folks solve their project dilemmas. Photo by RealWV.

As a salute to the hard-working men and women of hardware stores, we here at RealWV asked you to nominate your favorite local stores (no big box stores or chains allowed) for the “Best Local Hardware Stores in WV.” 

And boy oh boy, did you ever do just that! Our readers sent in over 250 nominations representing 37 local hardware stores in all parts of the state. Here they are: 

  1. Martin & Jones, Ronceverte
  2. Kittle’s, Union
  3. J&J Hardware, Victor
  4. Hinton Hardware, Hinton
  5. Means Lumber, Oak Hill
  6. Hardware That’s Us, Craigsville
  7. FM Pile Hardware, Charleston
  8. Zegeer Hardware, Charleston
  9. Liggett’s Supply, Mill Creek
  10. Baisden Brothers Hardware, Logan
  11. Hardman’s Hardware, 7 locations
  12. AJ Reece Hardware & Supply, Peterstown 
  13. Byrnside Hardware, Danville 
  14. McIntosh Hardware, Spencer
  15. Kennedy Hardware, Wheeling
  16. Buckeye Country Mart, Buckeye
  17. Hunter’s Hardware, Berkeley Springs
  18. Rexroad Supply, Alderson
  19. H&H Hardware, Thomas
  20. Martin’s Hardware, Pine Grove
  21. The Hardware Store, Martinsburg
  22. Green’s Feed & Seed, Charleston
  23. Country Hardware, Richwood
  24. Rogers Hardware, Pinch
  25. Adkins Home Center, Parsons
  26. 20th Street Hardware, Huntington
  27. Jimmy’s Hardware, Roderfield
  28. Street’s Store, Masontown
  29. 21 Country Market, Ripley
  30. EJ Wheeler/Bowman’s, Franklin
  31. Priddy’s Hardware, Crab Orchard
  32. Crawley Feed & More, Crawley
  33. Tygart River General Store, Belington
  34. Neathawk Lumber, Lewisburg
  35. Trickett’s Hardware, Elkins
  36. Center Hardware, St Albans 
  37. St Mary’s Hardware, St Mary’s

Next, we asked our readers to vote for their favorites. After thousands of votes were cast, the readers chose their Top 10: 

  1. Martin & Jones, Ronceverte
  2. Kittle’s, Union
  3. St Mary’s Hardware, St Mary’s
  4. Jimmy’s Hardware, Roderfield
  5. AJ Reece, Peterstown
  6. Crawley Feed & More, Crawley
  7. Hardiman’s Hardware, 7 locations
  8. J&J Hardware, Victor
  9. Hinton Hardware, Hinton
  10. Neathawk’s, Lewisburg 

Finally, with almost 10,000 votes cast, the readers chose their Top 5, which we are proud to recognize as the best local hardware stores in West Virginia: 

Jimmy’s Hardware, Roderfield

Martin & Jones, Ronceverte

Kittle’s, Union

J&J Hardware, Victor 

St. Mary’s Hardware, St. Mary’s

Thank you to all of our readers and each of the nominees for participating in this process. We look forward to writing feature stories on each of the Top 5 stores in the coming months. Stay tuned!