THE FRONT PORCH: Should there be stricter guidelines for voucher programs such as the Hope Scholarship?

By Dakota Baker, RealWV

What is the Hope Scholarship?

The Hope Scholarship is a voucher program and an education savings account (ESA) that allows families to use state education funding for alternative schooling  for K-12 students, such as homeschooling or private schools. 

The scholarship is used to cover educational expenses such as private school tuition and fees, tutoring, curriculum and materials, educational technology, transportation, and more. However, there are no income guidelines or household income limits. 

Are there standardized testing requirements?

Standardized testing is not required for students as an eligibility requirement, but academic progress reporting is required at the end of the academic year. 

For Hope Scholarship students participating in an Individualized Instructional Program, or IIP, two options are accepted when it comes to demonstrating a child’s academic progress:

  1. Nationally normed standardized achievement test in accordance with West Virginia Code §18-31-8(a)(4)(A)
  2. A certified teacher conducts a review of the student’s academic work annually and certifies the student is making academic progress commensurate with his or her age and ability. 

View the differences between Hope Scholarship Program Individualized Instruction Programs (IIP) and traditional homeschool requirements here. 

How much public school funding goes into the Hope Scholarship?

A child awarded with 100 percent funding through the Hope Scholarship would receive $5,435.62. This is an increased amount compared to the 2024-2025 school year, which was $4,921.39 per child. 

The funding for the program is drawn from the state’s general revenue and education funds. Our public education in West Virginia is largely funded through the state’s general revenue. State support for K-12 public schools is administered through the Public School Support Program, the seven-step school aid formula, which currently allocates roughly $1.4 billion to $1.8 billion in state funding for West Virginia’s 55-county public school system.

Back in April, it was announced that more than 20,000 students had applied for full funding for the Hope Scholarship for the 2026-2027 academic year — representing more thaan $100 million in potential awards. Those numbers have risen since and will continue to rise as more applications are submitted. 

Additionally, lawmakers allocated $277 million for the Hope Scholarship to account for any student who uses the program in the 2026-27 school year (more than 400% increase). 

What happens when a child exits the Hope Scholarship Program?

If a child who receives the scholarship returns to traditional public school, remaining funds in the child’s Hope Scholarship account are returned to the state. 

How does this program affect public schools?

There is concern over the loss of enrollment and funding. This concern comes from the significant drop in enrollment rates, with thousands of students leaving public school to utilize Hope Scholarship funds for private or homeschooling. 

Why is enrollment such a huge concern? State public school aid formulas are tied to enrollment, fewer students mean reduced state funding allocations for local districts.

Should voucher programs like the Hope Scholarship have stricter guidelines for income, how public funding is used, and how student academic progress is measured?

The full annual report from the 2025-2026 school year can be viewed here. Particularly interesting is how much money is being spent on out of state education.